Omega 3's and Mood Disorders


Mood and Anxiety problems are a disabling conditions in which life becomes a hopeless mess. In the past, this condition was called melancholy. You lose pleasure for things that brought you enjoyment in the past. In fact, it becomes difficult to conjure up previously happy times. Any motivation for the future, let alone the next day evaporates.

Mood conditions have increased significantly in the past century, with nearly 20 million people now affected by it. The increase in its incidence correlates very well with our decreasing intake of fish and fish oil in the same time period.

Psychiatric researchers learned several decades ago that decreased mood levels are often caused by lack of the neurotransmitter, serotonin. In fact, drug companies have made billions off of the development of drugs to boost serotonin levels like Prozac, Paxil, and Zoloft, all of which have become household names. More recent research has found that even people who have healthy mood levels experience an improvement in their moods when they take one of these drugs. What this indicates to me is that our nation has developed a serotonin deficiency.

Researchers believe the answer lies in our reduced intake of long-chain Omega 3 fatty acids. Since one of the benefits of high-dose fish oil is to increase serotonin levels, it is not unreasonable to think that the decrease in fish oil consumption in the past century led to a decrease in the natural levels of serotonin in the brain. Furthermore, using an imaging test known as SPECT, researchers have found that blood flow within a normal brain is uniform, whereas blood flow in patients with mood and anxiety problems is scattered with "holes" in which little or no blood flow is observed. Since high-dose fish oil can improve blood flow, we now have another potential clue to explain the molecular basis of these conditions. Finally, the Greenland Eskimos have virtually none of these conditions.

Could it be that simply eating a greater amount of fish is the answer to this growing incidence of mood and anxiety problems? If that is the case, then there should be a strong correlation between the amount of fish consumed and the extent of these conditions.

The rates of mood and anxiety problems in Japan are just a fraction of the rates in America and the rates in other countries where low amounts of fish are eaten. In fact, New Zealanders have 50 times the rate of the Japanese and eat the least amount of fish in the industrialized world. In native Greenland, Eskimos (who consume some 7-10 grams per day of long-chain Omega 3 fatty acids) have virtually none even though their living conditions can be pretty depressing with only an hour or two of sunlight a day during the winter months.

Epidemiological studies, however, only indicate association, not causality. Perhaps, the Japanese and Eskimos just have good genes, and the amount of fish they consume has nothing to do with it. (That's not what researchers believe, but such confounding factors can come into play with epidemiological studies.) That possibility is unlikely since animal studies demonstrate a significant increase in the amount of serotonin in the frontal cortex of their brains if they consume high-dose fish compared to animals that were given a standard diet rich in Omega 6 fats.

These animal studies have been verified by recent research in humans that indicates the AA/EPA ratio is highly elevated in the cerebrospinal fluid of patients with mood and anxiety problems when compared to patients with healthy mood levels. Likewise Belgian studies indicate that patients with mood and anxiety problems have lower levels of total Omega 3 fatty acids in their blood and a significantly higher AA/EPA ratio when compared to healthy individuals. British researchers have confirmed this observation.

One reason why increased consumption of fish oils would improve unhealthy mood conditions is through a reduction in AA levels. This would, in turn, lead to a reduction in the production of "bad" eicosanoids, such as PGE2, which is known to be present in much higher levels in the spinal fluid patients with mood and anxiety problems compared to healthy controls. In addition, researchers have found that the higher the intake of fish oil, the greater the improvement in the AA/EPA ratio. This ratio has also been found to correlate strongly with the severity of the problem.

All of these suggestive bits of research called out for an intervention study to determine the impact that high-dose fish oil could actually have in treating mood and anxiety conditions. Andrew Stoll and his colleagues at Harvard Medical School used exactly this approach in tackling the most severe forms of mood and anxiety conditions. These patients cycle from unhealthy mood levels to a manic high and then back again. The most common drugs prescribed for these conditions are lithium and valproate, both block the release of arachidonic acid in the brain. Unfortunately, both drugs (especially lithium) have significant toxic side effects. So a search for a safer alternative led Andrew to investigate the use of long-chain Omega 3 fatty acids found in fish oil.

In Stoll's experiment, one group of patients with this type of unhealthy mood levels took a refined fish oil containing 10 grams per day of long-chain Omega 3 fatty acids. The other group of patients took a placebo containing olive oil. After four months of the nine-month-long trial, the researchers ended the trial early because the divergence between the fish oil group and the control group was so great that they felt it was unethical to continue the study. (Another small complicating factor was that the supply of ultra- refined fish oil provided by the U.S. government had run out.) Even in this shortened trial, those on the high-dose fish experienced stabilization in their symptoms, while those on the olive oil control had a significant worsening of their symptoms.

Now the question is what was happening inside the brain to help alleviate this unhealthy mood level in the patients who took fish oil? A pretty good assumption is that serotonin levels increased in the brain's frontal cortex, as has already been demonstrated in animal experiments. Increased EPA consumption through fish oil supplementation also probably decreased the AA/EPA ratio in both the cerebrospinal fluid that bathes the brain and the blood lipids-which led to a corresponding decrease in mood and anxiety conditions. Such a decrease in the AA/EPA ratio would also reduce the levels of pro-inflammatory eicosanoids, which would cut off a cycle that leads to the production of "bad" eicosanoids such as PGE2 that is known to be increased in the depressed patients. Finally, high-dose fish oil almost certainly improved blood flow to the patients' brains providing a more uniform distribution of critical nutrients such as oxygen and glucose.

These are some complex and striking consequences for a relatively simple dietary intervention. Yet as dramatic as these result were, some believe they could have been even better if the Harvard researchers had brought these patients' insulin levels under control (through the Zone dietary recommendations) while supplementing with even higher levels of fish oil. A lower level of insulin would have further decreased the production of arachidonic acid, and thus enhanced the benefits of high-dose fish oil supplementation. In addition, lower insulin levels would have maintained a more constant supply of blood sugar to the brain.

 

 

Statements on this website have not been evaluated by the U.S. Food & Drug Administration. These products are not intended to diagnose, treat, cure or prevent any disease. Always consult your physician for advice.